After serving the department of school education for more than six years in Haryana, guest teachers are facing now difficult times with no fault of theirs, they were appointed by the state education department by a policy advertisement in leading newspapers in 2005.Then what went wrong? so many appointments were made in past at panchayat level and block level or district level ,they even regularized Then what created problems for guest teachers, see the following observations of high court :
" guest teachers are backdoor entrants and the State
has been virtually encouraging an unacceptable practice. The norms for
appointment of guest teachers, as originally set out by the policy guidelines
dated 17.12.2005, were thrown to the winds at the time of recruitment.
Instead a process of handpicking candidates for appointment had been
resorted to. Slowly but steadily vested rights, though limited, had been
conferred by making such engagements on contract basis for a fixed
duration against a consolidated pay. Such actions of the State amount to
perpetuation of an illegality which cannot be permitted on the touchstone of
Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India."
what are reasons court said guest teachers were handpicked and they are back door entrants, certainly this case was not handled properly. In the following observation court said article 14 and 16 of constitution is violated in guest teachers appointment.
The task before the Court, undoubtedly, is one of the striking
the right balance between the need for education and the need for
upholding the fundamental rights of a large section of the citizens under
Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India.
article 14 and 16 speaks about Right to Equality and Right to Equal opportunity for all in public appointments. Now it is surprising when there was a advertisement appeared in newspapers and that was open to all ; however there was preference to the candidates of the same village ,then block, and then district. When district level appointments are legal and are still going on ,then why not village level or block level are not legal? ,this again shows that this case was not perused well in court by the right approach.
following strong words of the court can create problems for guest teachers because their termination is automatic
"(1) While it will be open to the State to extend the tenure of the
guest teachers, at all levels, such extensions shall not be
beyond 31.03.2012. In fact, on the expiry of the said date i.e.
31.03.2012, the services of all the guest teachers shall be
understood to have lapsed in terms of the present order and it
will not be open for the State to continue any such guest
teacher in service"
in absence of any new order from court if they go to school on first April , head of school can show him/her this order of court and deny him/her to mark attendance. So these days of March are very crucial for guest teachers either they should approach the court for review of the decision or government should approach the court. Some also of the view that government can pass a bill in assembly to regularize the services of guest teachers. This option can also be explored but high court and Supreme court has the power to declare any bill 'null and void' if it against any of provisions of constitution of India. Courts have already observed that in these appointments article 14 and 16 is violated. Then what? If government introduce a bill in assembly and such a bill is passed ten certainly it will be challenged in the courts of law , in that case if government could convince the court that no violation of constitution has occurred then only guest teachers may be regularized. Let us hope for the best.
" guest teachers are backdoor entrants and the State
has been virtually encouraging an unacceptable practice. The norms for
appointment of guest teachers, as originally set out by the policy guidelines
dated 17.12.2005, were thrown to the winds at the time of recruitment.
Instead a process of handpicking candidates for appointment had been
resorted to. Slowly but steadily vested rights, though limited, had been
conferred by making such engagements on contract basis for a fixed
duration against a consolidated pay. Such actions of the State amount to
perpetuation of an illegality which cannot be permitted on the touchstone of
Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India."
what are reasons court said guest teachers were handpicked and they are back door entrants, certainly this case was not handled properly. In the following observation court said article 14 and 16 of constitution is violated in guest teachers appointment.
The task before the Court, undoubtedly, is one of the striking
the right balance between the need for education and the need for
upholding the fundamental rights of a large section of the citizens under
Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India.
article 14 and 16 speaks about Right to Equality and Right to Equal opportunity for all in public appointments. Now it is surprising when there was a advertisement appeared in newspapers and that was open to all ; however there was preference to the candidates of the same village ,then block, and then district. When district level appointments are legal and are still going on ,then why not village level or block level are not legal? ,this again shows that this case was not perused well in court by the right approach.
following strong words of the court can create problems for guest teachers because their termination is automatic
"(1) While it will be open to the State to extend the tenure of the
guest teachers, at all levels, such extensions shall not be
beyond 31.03.2012. In fact, on the expiry of the said date i.e.
31.03.2012, the services of all the guest teachers shall be
understood to have lapsed in terms of the present order and it
will not be open for the State to continue any such guest
teacher in service"
in absence of any new order from court if they go to school on first April , head of school can show him/her this order of court and deny him/her to mark attendance. So these days of March are very crucial for guest teachers either they should approach the court for review of the decision or government should approach the court. Some also of the view that government can pass a bill in assembly to regularize the services of guest teachers. This option can also be explored but high court and Supreme court has the power to declare any bill 'null and void' if it against any of provisions of constitution of India. Courts have already observed that in these appointments article 14 and 16 is violated. Then what? If government introduce a bill in assembly and such a bill is passed ten certainly it will be challenged in the courts of law , in that case if government could convince the court that no violation of constitution has occurred then only guest teachers may be regularized. Let us hope for the best.
43 comments: on "FUTURE OF GUEST TEACHERS IN HARYANA"
they certainly get regulaized...our best wishes are with them
Guest teachers should be sacked only if they have committed any crime. Government's policy at the time of their appointment should be scanned under circumstances. G.t's Made the future of students but under no secure future of their own. Just think
dear all if guest will be regularised then it will be injustice with all stet/htet qualified
firstly i have no sympathy with guests because when they were appointed it was a short term period. But still then they enjoys six years. Now its the time for new regular htet qualified teachers.if the guests are qualied they will get enough oppturnity like others.but they must get one time age relaxation of 5 years. Let them face the reality
Time has been changing in haryana.Those who are with guest teachers they are also currupt,Always go with those who are hard worker and believe in them.Htet/Ctet qualified people more qualified and intelligent than guest teachers.Govt. should give them their rights.If Guest teachers are hard workers they do not need to afraid.Compete those who have proved that they are eligible.Always go with right people and right decesions not with cheater and loosers.If you are with them This shows that you are also looser,cheater and feared person.
YEARNING FOR A JOB AT THE COST OF OTHERS IS A COWARDLY ACT...THERE ARE TWO LAKH STET/HTET PASS...WILL THEY ALL GET JOBS BY REMOVING JUST 15000 GUEST TEACHERS...HOW ONE CAN CLAIM THAT GT ARE LESS IN KNOWLEDGE...DEFICIENCIES EXIST EVERYWHERE...THEY ARE SUFFERING DUE TO A TECHNICAL ERROR IN THEIR RECRUITMENT..SO MANY GT HAVE CLEARED STET/HTET..THIS IS TOTALLY ABSURD TO SAY LIKE THIS..THIS MATTER IS SUB JUDICE..LET COURTS DECIDE THE MATTER..IF GT ARE TO BE REMOVED BY COURT..IT IS NOT DUE TO THAT THEY ARE FOOLS ETC..JUST DUE TO ERRORS IN THEIR RECRUITMENT...
Guest Teachers appointments are not valid. Chances are high DEO and principle of school can gave preference to a candidate. I know many guest teachers those gave money at DEO office and got appointments. Also why guest teachers, they should conduct recruitment at state level by giving equal rights to all citizens. With Guest teacher who stays at Ambala and have contacts in DEO office will be recruited.
Guest Teachers are on this position only due to present Government in haryana.at the time of guest teacher recruitment everybody is given equal rights, the one who is eligible that time get the job.secondly at that time there was no HTET in haryana so why today there is an issue whether guests teacher have cleared HTET or not.
still most of the GT has cleared the HTET exam.they need to be regularize as they had given there precious time to haryana education.
i also admit this thing that some guest teachers got their job by some unfair means.but it is nt fine to consider all guest teachers in the same category.us earlier mention in a comment there is huge no of guest teachers who cleared the STET.I am asking one question to those people who are not in favour of regularity of guest teachers(who are STET cleared) just think Urself in place of them and then answer the question. You all know the system. Rarely any body can get govt job without money. So if sum get chance to do the same we should support them.
I think why the preferance should be given to the candidate from the same village there w' r many village where we dont have a high or secondary school guest should be removed guest should not be owner
all of the htet qualified candidate are not to challenge the all govt. policies before the new one vaccancies , although htet aslike as the univercity degree as in procssses there is no way to make noice for the working peaple are honestly and improving the school education for little childeren ,all of you may help these people are working for your children,s wellfare
All htet, STet Qualified candidate should send message govtment soon bharite give us.
is haryana govt. is advertising vacancies in april,2012 ? any news about this?
And who says bribes are not paid in state level recruitments in haryana. see the track record of this governmrnt 80 % of recruitments are done from Rohtak, Sonipat & Jajjar alone. how someone can say that they will get a fair chance if recruitment is done at state level
Guest teacher should be restricted or remove the TET exam.
Guest teacher dont hav any right to continue according to aggrement
Those who are not able to qualify H-Tet (the very primary level to show that they can teach someone), should not try to demolish future of india (students). So government should take interest in future of students and appoint the qualified teachers.
all teachers who haven't cleared htet including permanent teachers should to be made to write htet..Then it will be full justice to new comers..:-)
dear all
GT have 6 year exprince.then they will clear htet and get parmanent job. All the GT I wish him to be parmanent.
DEAR ALL GT MOSTLY PERSON ARE WITH U.
dear all,
I belong village. there i mostly see the 75% Parmanent are not serious to children future. they were come late and mostly school times sit out side the class & in ur office. but the GT were honestly study children & be serious for children future. I am not a Teacher while i sopourt the GT beacuse the were honest in her job.
regards
sunil Attri
all gt will be regular one day at their confidence and with public copration .
best wish all gt
ram
Agar itne saal teaching karke bhi wo HTET nhi qualify
kr paye to unhe koi right nhi hai teacher banke studends
ka future barbad kre.......
I think Government should regularize at least those GT who have qualified HTET, as they already completed required qualifications
saalon guest trs ke regular hone me aapko kya problm hai....let them enjoy regular service
koon kahta htet apne aap pass kiya hai 2010 ki bharti mein too 70% munna bhai bharti hue hai jo ye kehte hai htet ko bharti kare or gust ko hatao jis waqt jbt bed mein test hota tha us waqt to tumhari no nahi aaya ab kahi jammu mp se dagree kharid laye or pase se htet karwa liya agar tum ek baab ki aolad ho to batao kitneo ne aap clear kiya guest teacher to yeh nahi kehte htet walo mat lago tum kyo kehte ho inko hato agar itani hi well qualified ho to all india mein kahi bhi competition fight karo gust teacher ko koi bhi nahi hattah sakta jab tak guesto mein saas baki hai gust apni nokari bachane ke liya apne koon ka katra 2 baha denge
When guest trs were appointed they fulfiled the terms and condition led by govt.at that times.but those who did not they have no rigth to stay on their post most of them have resaigned from their post and those are still must be given sevre punishment but just think about them who are well gualified and living and earninig for their wards what will happen to their wads if their parents be removed from their post.So it's mean thinking and mentality of those who have no positive thinking for guest trs.Good human beings dont have such low thiking.
They should be regularised becouse they serve more than six year and his maximum part of life given to growth of education in haryana.
guest tr chinta na kre bdi jldi regular hone wale h say surjewalw
jkshastri
guest teachers serve the nation by giving education at very reasonable price, now the time for getting prize from govt. Govt. should also regularised there job immidietely
They are Guests and they have to leave finally.
They are nit selected by any proper procedure. Nor any merit was considered during their selection, which is the most unfair part for their selection for their selection as regular teacher. Most of the selected guest teacher duffers and don't even qualify minimum qualification laid by the govt. for slection of regular teachers.
7 years k job bahut hoti hai,guest ko pakka karo yahi unki roji roti hai
when GT comes in Haryana then there is no any condition of HTET and they proov their work very honestly. So all GT will be regularised as soon as possible. Hope for God Bless all the Guest Teacher
i think goverment teacher is good in teaching.kya HTET pass karne walh hi pada sakte h.to Bhagt Singh n konsa TET PASS KIYA tha jesn sare Desh ko Deshprem ka path padya.
If GT performance is good in last seven years then they should be permanent,
guest teacher ko laga kar desh ke education system ko kamjor
na karo. jo HTET TEST PASS KARY job --- . sarkar court ka order na man kar guest teacher ko backdoor se under lana chhathi hi. kabi aage chal kar sarkar ke loogo ke lai pareshani (problamm na ban jay )
guest teachers are eligible bcoz they had cleared the b.ed entrance.and many of them have cleared there stat htet also.koi apko naukari offer kare to kya aap mana karogae.aajkal jo htet wale khud ko eligible maan rahe hai unme se aadhon se to b.ed entrance bhe clear ni hota tha.ab entrance khatam kar diya to b.ed. kar li .gt ne to b.ed ka entrance bhe clear kiya tha or bahut saro ne htet bhe clear kar rakha hai.and above that govt job kisi ke pusthani jaysad ni hai jis par guest teachers ne kabja kar rakha ho.govt ne offer ki tabhi. lage we teacher.apne aap jake kisi bhe school me ni bath gae.and patr adhayapak sangh walo main bhe patr hoon lakin gt ke khilaf ni.kisi ke jagah cheen kar kisi kp dukh daker khus rahne ki koshish karogae to lush aap bhe ni reh paogae.
guest teachers are eligible bcoz they had cleared the b.ed entrance.and many of them have cleared there stat htet also.koi apko naukari offer kare to kya aap mana karogae.aajkal jo htet wale khud ko eligible maan rahe hai unme se aadhon se to b.ed entrance bhe clear ni hota tha.ab entrance khatam kar diya to b.ed. kar li .gt ne to b.ed ka entrance bhe clear kiya tha or bahut saro ne htet bhe clear kar rakha hai.and above that govt job kisi ke pusthani jaysad ni hai jis par guest teachers ne kabja kar rakha ho.govt ne offer ki tabhi. lage we teacher.apne aap jake kisi bhe school me ni bath gae.and patr adhayapak sangh walo main bhe patr hoon lakin gt ke khilaf ni.kisi ke jagah cheen kar kisi kp dukh daker khus rahne ki koshish karogae to lush aap bhe ni reh paogae.
guest teachers are eligible bcoz they had cleared the b.ed entrance.and many of them have cleared there stat htet also.koi apko naukari offer kare to kya aap mana karogae.aajkal jo htet wale khud ko eligible maan rahe hai unme se aadhon se to b.ed entrance bhe clear ni hota tha.ab entrance khatam kar diya to b.ed. kar li .gt ne to b.ed ka entrance bhe clear kiya tha or bahut saro ne htet bhe clear kar rakha hai.and above that govt job kisi ke pusthani jaysad ni hai jis par guest teachers ne kabja kar rakha ho.govt ne offer ki tabhi. lage we teacher.apne aap jake kisi bhe school me ni bath gae.and patr adhayapak sangh walo main bhe patr hoon lakin gt ke khilaf ni.kisi ke jagah cheen kar kisi kp dukh daker khus rahne ki koshish karogae to lush aap bhe ni reh paogae.
Jo log guest ka oppose karte hain vo sab corrupt hain.Sabko pata hai agar bharti nikli tou vahi lagenge jinka naam mla ya kisi mantri ki list mein hoga.jiski kahin sifarish nahi hai vo haryana govt ki naukri k khawab b nahin dekhta.ab jo halla kar rahe hain vo talented nahin balki sifarsi hain
if htet and stet is qualified teacher then the posting before 2006 is not qualified teacher
3206 JBT TEACHER 1984 PTI ACHI BHARTI HAIN........... PER % KI GYI BHARTI ACHI BHARTI NHI HAIN..., WAH! KESA NYAY HAIN ... :) :)
If you are looking as secure career in education sector then B.ed is the best
option to become a good teacher. I am persuaing B.ed course from SSB Education
Society. It is the Best B.ed college in Rohtak. you can also visit their website
http://www.ssbedugroup.com/
YOUR OPINION COUNTS :Have any questions or comments? Participate in the discussions today. Use the form below to ask your questions and share your ideas.